North American Insurance Company has some very interesting things going on with it. For starters, it is currently not taking on any new business; however, it is still managing policies (including their signature North American Insurance Medicare Plans) and paying out claims for existing customers. This change could have something to do with its merger into Oxford Life/AMERCO in recent years.

  • North American Insurance
  • North American
  • North American Insurance Company

Company Highlights

  • Specializes in Medicare supplement (Medigap) insurance
  • Administers premiums and claims for more than 60,000 policyholders
  • Proud Member of the Oxford Life family of companies
  • Subsidiary of AMERCO

Medicare Plans Offered

Back when North American Insurance was taking on new policies, they offered:

Medicare Supplement Plans YES
Medicare Advantage Plans NO
Medicare Part D Drug Plans NO

North American Insurance Premium Comparison

While getting a free quote is the best way to know whether or not North American will give you a good deal, you can at least get some perspective with the graph below. The following data is based on average rates across the country:
This Table Represents National Average Costs of Medicare Supplement Plans

Plan Type Starting From Part A Deductible Part B Deductible Excess Nursing Travel
Plan C $118* $0 $0 Not Covered 100% Covered 100% Covered
Plan F $116* $0 $0 100% Covered 100% Covered 100% Covered
Plan G $105* $0 $233 100% Covered 100% Covered 100% Covered
Plan B $104* $0 $233 Not Covered Not Covered Not Covered
Plan N $70* $0 $233 Not Covered 100% Covered 100% Covered
Plan D $97* $0 $233 Not Covered 100% Covered 100% Covered
Plan A $69* $1,556 $233 Not Covered Not Covered Not Covered
Plan L $76* $389 $233 Not Covered 75% Covered Not Covered
Plan K $45* $778 $233 Not Covered 50% Covered Not Covered
Plan M $97* $778 $233 Not Covered 100% Covered 100% Covered

Financial Strength Ratings

Below, the top 3 credit and financial reporting agencies have weighed in on how well they think North American Insurance is performing, financially speaking. Right now, the company is rated:

A.M. Best Rating B++
Standard & Poor’s Rating No Rating
Moody’s Rating No Rating

*Ratings as of 2/17/15

North American Insurance Review

Sadly, North American Insurance is not taking on any new business at this time. However, they are still managing over 60,000 policies acquired while they were still active. They are now a member of the Oxford Life family of companies.

  • Market Experience
  • Fast Claims Processing
  • Strong Financial Reserves
  • Competitive Rates
  • Customer Satisfaction

How To File A Claim With North American Insurance

Telephone Number: (877) 469-3073

To speak with a person:

  1. Press “4” for “Policy Holders”
  2. You will then be transferred to a live customer service representative

Company Contact Information

Customer Service:

(877) 469-3073

Mailing Address:

North American Insurance Company

PO Box 46518

Madison, WI 53744-6518

How To Get A Rate Quote

Customers looking to get a rate quote, or learn more about plans have 2 options:

  • Call a licensed insurance representative at: (833) 972-1339
  • Complete an online quote request at:

Picture of the author
by Lindsay Malzone, Lindsay Malzone is the Medicare expert for She's been contributing to many well-known publications as an industry expert since 2017. Her passion is educating Medicare beneficiaries on all their supplemental Medicare options so they can make an informed decision on their healthcare coverage.