New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans, commonly called “Medigap plans,” are additional forms of coverage tacked onto Original Medicare policies. These federal government-standardized packages offer users benefits they wouldn’t have with a barebones Medicare plan.

Here, we’ll look at some of the popular Medicare Supplement plans offered in New Jersey and their key differences.

New Jersey Medicare Supplement enrollment

New Jersey has one of the highest Medigap enrollment rates of any state. Over 480,000 New Jersey citizens are covered with a Medicare Supplement plan, nearly 37% of the state’s population. That percentage exceeds many neighboring ‘big-name’ markets, including New York, Connecticut, and Massachusetts.

  6,709 2,825 61,290 1,817 193,882 72,809 3,276 2,846 8 87,811

What are the top Medigap plans in New Jersey?

Plan F is the most sought-after Medigap plan in the state, which aligns with most other states’ preferences. Specifically, Plan F accounts for over 190,000 of the state’s 480,000 Medigap enrollees.

Other popular plans include Plan G (72,809 enrollees), Plan N (87,811 enrollees), and Plan C (61,290 enrollees).

medicare supplement enrollees per plan in new jersey

Medigap plan coverage chart for New Jersey

Many first-time enrollees for New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans don’t know where to begin with the options available. Luckily, the federal government standardizes the coverage, and the benefits included in each plan stay the same regardless of the state, making them easy to research.

Medicare Supplement plans costs in New Jersey

Despite the benefits in each Medicare Supplement Plan remaining equal from state to state, the costs of each plan are subject to wild change. You might end up paying more or less for your Medigap coverage depending on the following factors:

  • Where do you live & where did you enroll
  • Age and gender
  • History of tobacco use
  • Specific household discounts
  • And more

Visit our FAQ and learn more about the factors driving your Medigap coverage’s price.

medicare supplement costs in new jersey

What’s the average cost for a Medicare Supplement plan in New Jersey?

The cost of New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans vary due to a few factors. The monthly premiums range from $90 to $185.

Inexpensive premium per Medigap letter plan in New Jersey

New Jersey offers a few Medigap plans with low premium payments under $100 on average. The prices listed below are for the typical 65-year-old woman but can provide a clear barometer for the general cost of each plan.

Premium $103 $139 $163 $126 $154 $127 $50 $80 $93 $98

Highest premium per Medigap letter plan in New Jersey

On the other hand, some New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans require high premium payments for increased benefits.

The numbers in the chart below simulate the average male near 70. As you can see, paying a $300+ premium for the state’s most popular plans is not uncommon.

Premium $284 $391 $515 $384 $466 $453 $150 $220 $254 $348

Top Medicare Supplement plan carriers in New Jersey

New Jersey has a wide selection of Medicare Supplement plan providers, each offering the state’s most sought-after plans at different price points. Here, we’ll look at a few of the most well-known providers and what the average 70-year-old woman pays for coverage per plan.

The Capitol $173 $143 $114
Royal Arcanum $174 $145 $113
Central States $174 $150 $114
Federal Life $177 $150 $118
Humana $177 $150 $118

New Jersey cities with Medicare Supplement coverage’s estimated premiums

The below cities in New Jersey have a large concentration of Medicare recipients. Here are some illustrative charts on their projected Medigap plan costs:


How much does Medigap cost in New Jersey?

The cost of New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans varies on several factors, including the enrollee’s age, gender, and the selected program. It’s challenging to pinpoint an exact price point with that high variance, but New Jersey enrollees have widely accepted averages.

What do Medigap policies cover in New Jersey?

You can gain access to the following benefits not included in standard Medicare, depending on your selected Medigap policy:

Not every Medicare Supplement plan includes these benefits, but your provider will walk you through the specifics of each option to help you find your perfect fit.

What is the most comprehensive Medicare Supplement plan in New Jersey?

Plan F offers the most Medicare benefits of any of New Jersey’s Medicare Supplement plans, which is why it’s the state’s most popular plan. But you should note that while Plan F does include the most coverage, it’s also the most expensive Medigap plan.

Is Medigap the same as Medicare Supplement plans in New Jersey?

There is no difference between Medigap plans and Medicare Supplement plans. Both are additional healthcare packages that offer unique benefits on top of your standard Medicare.

Can you have two Medicare Supplement plans in New Jersey?

Medicare Supplement providers are legally barred from selling multiple plans to the same person. However, depending on their needs, different members of the same family or household can have their own plans.

Suppose you’re concerned about insufficient coverage with just one Medicare Supplement plan. In that case, your best bet is to enroll with Plan F. This package offers every benefit included across Medigap, but you will need to pay more for that extensive coverage.

How to sign up for a Medicare Supplement plan in New Jersey

Researching New Jersey’s various providers and each package’s specific pros and cons can be time-consuming and confusing. Enrolling in a Medicare Supplement plan is often challenging for potential users.

But if you want to enhance your health coverage and spare yourself a headache, we’re here to help. Our licensed insurance agents offer free service to all New Jersey residents and work with every Medicare Supplement provider so that we can bring you hassle-free coverage that leaves no stone unturned.

Our team compares every rate for all New Jersey Medicare Supplement plans across the sea of providers so that you can get the rates and benefits that work for your budget and medical needs. Medicare Supplement coverage can help you live a happier, healthier life with peace of mind for your well-being, and we can help bring the best possible plan into your life today.

Call us today to learn more about New Jersey’s Medicare options, or complete our online form to connect with the best rates in your area.

Written By:
Picture of the author
Lindsay Malzone, Lindsay Malzone is the Medicare editor for She's been contributing to many well-known publications since 2017. Her passion is educating Medicare beneficiaries on all their supplemental Medicare options so they can make an informed decision on their healthcare coverage.
Reviewed By:
Picture of the expert
Rodolfo Marrero, Rodolfo Marrero is one of the co-founders at He has been helping consumers find the right coverage since the site was founded in 2013. Rodolfo is a licensed insurance agent that works hand-in-hand with the team to ensure the accuracy of the content.