Traditional Medicare (Medicare Parts A and B) is the federal healthcare program designed to help senior citizens fulfill their challenging overall health needs during their golden years. This program is fairly comprehensive, but there are several charges – sometimes called “gaps” in coverage – which may become expensive when you don’t have any alternative coverage in place. For a lot of elderly people, the solution to this challenge is usually a Medigap (Medicare Supplement) insurance plan. Any senior-citizen age 65+ who is currently signed up for Medicare can apply for a Medigap policy.

Federal Regulations for Medicare Supplements

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) are responsible for regulating Medigap plans. This helps make sure that, of the 10 accessible plans, all insurance providers in all 50 states provide the exact same plans and coverage options. In this way, the main difference from one insurer to another is the cost of your monthly premium.

Medigap Enrollment In Indiana

There are just under 300,000 seniors who call Indiana home, and who also have their Medicare gaps covered by Medicare supplement insurance. Of those, the biggest percentage of members are subscribed to Plan F, which you can see for yourself in this chart.

Plan Type A B C D E F G H I J K L M N
Enrollment 4,398 4,308 17,535 5,357 4,243 184,680 28,515 802 2,546 13,638 693 5,211 22 14,941

Plan Coverage & Cost

Health insurance – along with the cost for it – are personalized to you, the individual. Your weight, smoking habits, age, gender, and precise location will all affect the monthly premiums you pay for a Medicare supplemental insurance policy.

Monthly premiums for a Medicare Supplement Plan will vary by the individual. Being in good health and avoiding unhealthy habits like smoking will help get you a lower rate. Older seniors, smokers, and certain genders may have to pay a higher premium for their plan. Most importantly, however, is your ZIP code. If you’re worried about the final cost, be sure to shop around between different providers for the most affordable monthly rate. Below are some estimates from Medicare supplement companies in your area:

Most Popular Medicare Supplement Plans in Indiana

As mentioned earlier, more Indiana seniors rely upon Plan F than any of the other 10 available plans. Plan F is the simplest plan to manage because it covers all of the Medicare gaps – meaning all you have to do, even in the event of a health emergency, is pay your monthly premium. The rest will be taken care of by Medicare, or your Medigap company.

Plans N and C rank a distant 2nd and 3rd, respectively. These plans focus more on covering the gaps in Part A of Medicare, with some coverage of Part B gaps. If you are more concerned with expensive hospital visits, and less so with doctor bills, these might be better plans for you.

How do Medicare Plan Ratings Work?

The star rating we use is our best way of conveying to you the quality of a particular plan. Many seniors want to know how well their chronic conditions, tests, screenings, and other healthcare needs will be managed from a company. Others want to make sure they’re getting good customer service for most financially sound provider. The higher the star rating, the better service you can expect from that insurance company.

Helpful Medigap Tips & Tricks

Doctor/Provider Network Restrictions

The best thing about Medicare supplement insurance is related to how it encourages seniors to choose their individual medical doctors and facilities. Medicare supplemental insurance isn’t your only option for supplementing your Medicare coverage. Nevertheless, it is one of the few policies which won’t reduce your options to a restricted network of doctors and facilities that are pre-approved by your plan. Any doctor or hospital which takes Medicare is going to be available to you with a Medicare supplemental insurance policy. This is an excellent alternative for golden-agers who vacation, or dwell a long way away from large metropolitan areas.

Doctors List

One of the strong suits of a Medicare Supplement plan is the variety of choice you have when it comes to your healthcare needs. You can visit any healthcare provider who accepts Medicare assignment if you have a Medicare Supplement plan. “Medicare assignment” means that your doctor has agreed to work with Medicare and accept their pricing policies. Your doctor’s office increases this convenience for you by filing claims on your behalf. You only have to worry about paying the coinsurance, co-payment, and/or applicable deductibles as outlined by your policy. Search for doctors here.

Drug, Vision and Dental Coverage

Medicare Part D is now primarily accountable for providing seniors with prescription drug coverage. Due to this, it is no longer required for Medigap policies to supply prescription drug coverage as being an option. Vision and dental are extra varieties of coverage which Medicare supplement and Medicare will not pay for. You have the option to either acquire those coverages privately on your own, or to pay out-of-pocket if you find it less costly than insurance coverage.

Enrollment Options & Best Time To Enroll

For quick enrollment with virtually no hassle, you’ll need to register for a Medicare supplement policy around the time you enroll in Medicare (within your first 6 months of Medicare coverage, to be exact). The more you wait, the more difficult the process can become.

  • Initial Enrollment Period: Enroll in a Medicare supplemental insurance plan within your first 6 months of obtaining Medicare benefits, and you won’t be asked any unpleasant health questions or turned down coverage.
  • Guaranteed Issue: Common among seniors who are losing an employer or group health plan. The company you apply to will have to accept and cover you, no matter your existing health status.
  • Annual Enrollment Period (AEP): Medigap enrollment isn’t restricted by Annual Enrollment Periods the way other insurance policies are, so feel free to enroll whenever you want.
  • Underwritten: In the event you miss the IEP and don’t meet the requirements for Guarantee Issue, you may have to go through the underwriting process. This ordinarily involves queries about your health, and even a medical exam in order to evaluate whether or not your insurer can cover you.

Free Look Period

For your protection, there’s a 30 day “Free Look” examination period for each and every Medicare supplement policy issued. You have 30 days from your initial day of coverage to decide whether your coverage fits your needs. If you decide to go in a different direction, you can stop the policy and get a full refund.

What Medigap Plan Is Best For Me?

Most seniors have so many Medigap providers to choose from that it’s difficult to make the right choice. We’ve created a database of Medicare Supplement providers in your area for your convenience. Each company profile contains important details like quality of service and financial stability. This is important information that you need to reflect upon before you decide on a provider.

When it comes to choosing a specific plan, don’t rush into anything. You have to make a decision based on what you can afford, what your future needs may be, and how reliable you can expect your provider to be. The more accurately you can estimate all of these variables, the easier it will be to get the most value for your money.

by Lindsay Malzone, Lindsay Malzone is the Medicare expert for She's been contributing to many well-known publications as an industry expert since 2017. Her passion is educating Medicare beneficiaries on all their supplemental Medicare options so they can make an informed decision on their healthcare coverage.